In the competitive world of professional speaking, the difference between getting regularly booked and paid to speak and getting overlooked often comes down to one all-important factor: niche clarity. Unfortunately, many talented aspiring speakers unknowingly sabotage themselves by falling into a common trap – believing that casting the widest possible net will lead to the most paid speaking gigs.
Surprisingly, the reality is exactly the opposite. Although it might seem counterintuitive to some, vague and overly broad niches don’t expand your market; they often remove you from consideration entirely. This common misunderstanding can have disastrous consequences on promising speaking careers, costing speakers bookings, referrals and credibility.
In this article, we’ll take you through why niche clarity is so important, the mistakes that lead to vague niches, and how to confidently define your speaking niche so you can build a thriving speaking career.
Get The #1 Marketing Asset To Book More Paid Speaking Gigs
Join us for the Booked & Paid Bootcamp — our NEW 2-day virtual event designed to help you start booking more paid gigs FAST.
Over two 5+ hour days of live training and Q&A, our team of 6 and 7 figure speakers will give you the proven playbook you need to become a successful paid speaker.
When “Everything” Becomes Nothing
To help illustrate this common mistake in the speaking industry, imagine the following scenario: an event planner is searching for a keynote speaker on leadership development for their healthcare conference. They receive two proposals:
- Speaker A describes themselves as “a motivational speaker covering leadership, teamwork, communication, and personal development for all industries.”
- Speaker B positions themselves as “a former ICU director who helps healthcare leaders reduce burnout while maintaining exceptional patient care standards in crisis situations.”
Which speaker do you think will draw the attention of the event planner and command the higher fee? Obviously, it’s Speaker B, every single time.
This example perfectly illustrates the importance of positioning yourself with a well-defined niche. Speaker A thinks they are appealing to the widest possible audience, when in reality, every audience they think they’re appealing to will favor an industry specialist with deep expertise about a topic over an expansive generalist.
The Credibility Crisis of Vague Positioning
A lack of clarity about your speaking topic and target audience can cause speakers an array of problems. Here are some of the ways vague niches can hurt your speaking business:
The Expertise Problem
When you claim to speak about everything, you’re implicitly claiming to have expertise in an impossibly wide range of areas. That immediately raises credibility questions among event planners or conference organizers. True expertise requires focus, experience and a depth of knowledge that can only come from sustained attention to the industry and topic you speak on.
A speaker who addresses “leadership, sales, customer service, innovation, change management, and team building” lacks the concentrated experience that creates genuine authority. This scattered approach suggests they’ve never gone deep enough in any single area to develop truly valuable insights.
Event planners and meeting organizers understand this instinctively. They’re not looking for someone who knows a little about everything; they want someone who knows everything about their specific challenge.
To use the example from earlier, the healthcare event organizers don’t need generic leadership advice. They need someone who understands the industry – the unique pressures of healthcare leadership, the regulatory environment, the life-and-death stakes, and the specific cultural dynamics of medical organizations.
The Memorability Problem
Memorable first impressions are incredibly important when introducing yourself to event planners as a public speaker. Vague or overly broad niches can pose a big problem to your goal of standing out. When someone asks what you speak about, a rambling list of topics creates confusion. This is very likely to make your potential client forget you as soon as the conversation ends.
Compare these elevator pitches:
- “I speak on leadership, motivation, sales, customer service, change management, team building, and helping people reach their potential across various industries”
- “I help manufacturing leaders reduce workplace accidents while increasing productivity by implementing safety cultures that engage frontline workers”
The second speaker will be remembered, referred, and requested. The first will be forgotten before the conversation ends. More importantly, the second speaker’s focused positioning makes it easy for others to identify perfect opportunities and make confident referrals.
The Referral Problem
Referrals are incredibly important when trying to get consistent speaking gigs, but vague niches kill referral potential. When someone can’t easily explain what you do in one clear sentence, they won’t refer you. That’s not because they don’t want to help, but because they can’t confidently connect you with appropriate opportunities.
Your network needs to understand exactly who you serve and what problem you solve to connect you with relevant opportunities. Broad positioning places an unfair burden on your referral sources, asking them to remember and communicate multiple different value propositions for different audiences.
Mistakes That Lead to a Lack of Niche Clarity
As we’ve seen, a lack of unique niche clarity in the public speaking industry can severely limit your ability to consistently get paid speaking gigs. But aside from misconceptions about the need for niche clarity, what are the mistakes that cause this lack of clarity?
Lack of Industry Clarity
The industry you work with is an important part of your identity as a public speaker, and it helps event planners to be more confident that you have relevant experience and insight for their audience. But many speakers list every industry they’ve ever worked with, believing this demonstrates versatility and maximizes their potential market. Think of a speaker website that reads: “John has worked with healthcare, technology, manufacturing, finance, retail, education, and government organizations.”
Instead of showing off your versatility, this actually shows a potential client that you haven’t found your real calling and developed true expertise in an industry. Insider industry knowledge is crucial both to demonstrate your competence and expertise to clients, but also to enable you to truly speak to your audience’s greatest need.
A wide range of industries in your marketing materials raises immediate questions: If you’ve worked in all these industries, do you really understand any of them? Where have you achieved the most significant results? What unique insights have you developed?
While choosing an industry doesn’t mean you have to unequivocally reject any gig outside of it, it tremendously helps to define your focus and lends credibility to your message. At The Speaker Lab, we generally divide public speaking opportunities into seven key industries:
- Corporations
- Associations
- Nonprofits
- Churches/Faith-based Organizations
- Government and Military
- Colleges and Universities
- Education (K-12)
These industries vary widely in how much they pay, the kind of speakers they require and the kind of events you’ll speak at, but you should generally try to focus on one of these industries. Think about whether you have relevant experience or expertise in any of them. These industries are still pretty general, which is why even further narrowing down is often necessary.
Lack of Audience Clarity
To truly know who you speak to, you need more than just the industry type. To understand the problems your audience struggles with, you need to put yourself in their shoes. Doing that requires a specific knowledge of an archetype you want to speak to. Obviously you should avoid getting too specific here, but claiming to speak to CEOs, managers, and frontline employees in any corporation about the same topic reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of audience needs.
Different groups face different challenges, and require different kinds of solutions. For example, executives are often focused on high-level problems and looking for strategic insights – think topics relating to company growth or strategy implementation. When speaking to them about more personal topics, such as avoiding burnout or work-life balance, this will be in the context of their important and demanding positions.
Contrast that with managers, who might be looking for solutions for managing teams, or frontline employees who need motivation and specific skills. Trying to address all of them simultaneously with the same content satisfies none of them completely.
But effectively knowing who your audience is and speaking directly to their needs requires topic specificity, which leads us to the next mistake speakers make when defining their niche.
Lack of Topic Clarity
Perhaps the most damaging mistake is listing multiple unrelated speaking topics on your website or marketing materials. Speakers who promote themselves as experts in, for example, “leadership, time management, stress reduction, team building, communication, sales, and customer service” signal that they’re trying to be all things to all people.
This approach dilutes your expertise and confuses potential clients about your credentials. It also makes it impossible for you to develop the content, stories, and insights that make speakers truly memorable and valuable.
The most successful speakers build their entire personal brand around one topic, then scale their speaking business around solving that core problem. All the secondary content and presentations you produce will be approaching your signature content from other angles or mediums.
Lack of Benefit Clarity
The final mistake speakers make when positioning themselves is being unclear about the benefits they provide to their audience. Generic benefits like “increased productivity,” “better communication,” “improved leadership,” and “enhanced team performance” apply to almost every business topic. These vague promises don’t differentiate you or help buyers understand your unique value proposition.
Everyone claims to improve productivity and communication. What specific type of productivity? Communication in what context? Leadership of who and in what situations? The lack of specificity makes it impossible for potential clients to understand why they should choose you over the dozens of other speakers making similar claims.
Aim to be very specific about not only the problem you solve, but the solutions you provide to your audience.
Putting it Together: The Expert Positioning Statement
Now that you have understand the need for a specific industry, audience, topic and benefit you provide, it’s time to put it all together. You should be able to frame your speaking business in a short and succinct statement that follows this format: “I help (GROUP) do (TOPIC) so they can (BENEFIT).” This memorable formula is known as your Expert Positioning Statement (EPS).
This is a valuable way of quickly explaining what you speak about and the benefits you provide to anyone who may be interested. Crucially, it makes you easily referable, as event planners and other speakers will be able to easily articulate your value to colleagues.
Find Out Exactly How Much You Could Make As a Paid Speaker
Use The Official Speaker Fee Calculator to tell you what you should charge for your first (or next) speaking gig — virtual or in-person!
Conclusion
The speakers who thrive in a competitive market aren’t those who try to appeal to everyone; they’re the ones who serve a specific niche and become indispensable to their target market. By avoiding the common mistakes that lead to vague positioning and embracing focused expertise, you’ll transform yourself from another voice in the crowd into the obvious choice for your specific audience.
The path to speaking success isn’t about casting the widest net; it’s about becoming the best solution for a specific problem. As you establish expertise in your topic and field, you’ll notice an increase in your bookings as you become the go-to expert in your niche.
