Life Coach vs. Therapist: Choosing Your Growth Partner

Table of Contents

Ever found yourself weighing the pros and cons of getting a life coach versus seeing a therapist? If so, you’re not alone. Many people ponder which path will lead them to personal growth or emotional healing.

In this article, we’ll dive into what sets life coaches apart from therapists, starting with their unique roles, goals, and even their educational backgrounds. From there, we’ll tackle when it’s best to lean towards one over the other, whether you’re gunning for career success or working through deeper issues. By the end of our talk, you’ll have a clearer picture of who can help steer your ship in rough waters—and how they do it.

Understanding the Roles of Life Coaches and Therapists

Picking between a life coach and a therapist requires understanding the purpose of each role. While life coaches are equipped to help you achieve life or career goals, therapists are better suited to helping you understanding your behaviors.

Educational Background and Training

Therapists often hold advanced degrees that require years of study, such as psychology or social work. Their training equips them with deep insights into mental health disorders, allowing them to unravel complex emotional issues. Life coaches might not always have similar academic credentials but they do undergo certification processes from institutions like the International Coach Federation (ICF), sharpening their skills in guiding clients towards goal achievement.

A therapist’s education prepares them for clinical assessment. In other words, they can shed light on how past experiences shape present behavior. Meanwhile, life coaching focuses more on where you are now and how to move forward effectively—think actionable strategies rather than analysis.

Scope of Practice and Limitations

Thanks to their training in psychology, therapists can diagnose and treat mental illnesses. They’re equipped to deal with deep-seated psychological issues that may go beyond the scope of a life coach, whose expertise lies elsewhere—in motivation land. A life coach excels at pushing you toward personal milestones but steps back when it comes down to treating conditions like depression or anxiety—that’s therapist territory.

Both professionals follow ethical guidelines specific to their field ensuring that, whatever your needs, you will receive proper care whichever route you take.

Methodologies and Techniques Employed

When it comes to methodologies, therapists dig through your mental attic looking for root causes—the “whys” behind behaviors—with techniques ranging from cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) to psychoanalysis. Life coaches, on the hand, give you tools that help you set goals and create action plans.

So while one delves into understanding the intricacies of the human psyche in order to help you embrace healthier behavior patterns (“Tell me about your childhood…”), another helps clients aiming high with personalized game plans forged through robust coaching methodologies (“What steps will get us there?”). Both play critical roles—it just depends on whether you plan on exploring inner landscapes or charting new external territories.

Free Download: 6 Proven Steps to Book More Paid Speaking Gigs in 2024​

Download our 18-page guide and start booking more paid speaking gigs today!

The Educational Background and Training

Think of life coaches as the personal trainers for your goals, while therapists are like specialized doctors for your mind. Both occupations require unique educational training.

Educational Requirements for Life Coaches

Becoming a life coach might not require a formal degree, but don’t let that fool you into thinking anyone can pick up a whistle and start coaching. The International Coach Federation (ICF), one of the leading bodies in certifying life coaches, has laid out comprehensive training programs. These include hours upon hours of client-coaching experience and rigorous exams on ethical standards and coaching mastery. A certified coach often undergoes training specifically tailored to motivate clients toward their loftiest career or personal milestones.

A few workshops won’t cut it—serious coaches invest time in extensive courses from institutions like Coach Training Alliance or Co-Active Training Institute. They dive deep into human behavior patterns and goal-setting strategies because they’re passionate about giving people that “eureka” moment when everything clicks. Learn more about becoming a life coach here.

Educational Journey to Becoming a Therapist

Therapists run an academic marathon; there’s no sprinting here. They need at least a master’s degree in psychology, social work, counseling, or another related field just to get started. In addition, they need thousands of supervised clinical hours spent practicing their trade before they can be licensed by state boards such as the Association of Social Work Boards (ASWB).

Many pursue further specialization through doctoral programs or additional certifications from places like the American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP). This isn’t light reading we’re talking about; these folks read stacks upon stacks of textbooks so they can understand the ins and outs of the human psyche.

If you’re wondering why someone would go through all this trouble, it’s simple: therapists aim to treat mental health issues by using years’ worth of scientific study and practice guidelines. While both therapists and life coaches help navigate life’s complexities, their tools come sharpened by very different whetstones.

Scope of Practice and Limitations

A life coach might seem like a therapist’s doppelganger at first glance. On closer inspection, however, they play by different rules. Think of a life coach as your personal GPS for setting goals—they’ll help you plot the route and keep you on track to your destination. A therapist, though, is more like an expert mechanic who dives deep under the hood to fix complex issues with your engine—the inner workings of your mind.

The Issues Life Coaches Address

Life coaches are all about action and accountability in areas such as career growth or relationship building. They’re not here to unpack childhood memories or help you understand why you felt so down last week; that’s out of bounds for them. Instead, they gear up to motivate you into becoming the CEO of Your Life Inc., helping craft strategies for success that stick.

The Duties Therapists Hold

On the flip side, therapists come armed with degrees that help them navigate mental health disorders—something strictly off-limits for life coaches. They use their expertise within regulated confines dictated by licensing boards.

If ever there was an ethical booby trap in these professions, it’s scope creep. Broadly defined, scope creep occurs when the scope of a project gets bigger and bigger, usually because the scope was not well defined to begin with. In instances like this, lines can blur between coaching and therapy sessions, leaving clients confused about what service they’re actually getting (and potentially muddling legalities). Both therapists and life coaches must stay vigilant so that this doesn’t happen.

Methodologies and Techniques Employed

The methodologies and techniques employed by life coaches vary from those therapists use. Let’s take a look.

Life Coaching Strategies

A life coach is like a personal trainer for your goals. They use tools such as the GROW model, which stands for Goals, Reality, Options, and Will. Think of it this way: imagine you’re at a crossroads in your career path. A life coach acknowledges your goals, assesses where you are, suggests different options, and then equips you with the tools and motivation you need (goals, reality, options, will).

Moreover, coaches often lean on positive psychology to fuel progress. This isn’t just “feel-good” talk; it’s about harnessing what works well in your life to power through challenges.

Therapeutic Approaches

In contrast, therapists might dive into Cognitive Behavioral Therapy or CBT. Picture someone gently helping untangle a knot of negative thoughts so that each thread can be examined separately.

Sometimes they’ll use more dynamic methods like Dialectical Behavior Therapy or DBT. Based on CBT, this type of therapy is particularly helpful for people who experience intense emotions (especially negative ones) and need help regulating them.

The session flow also varies greatly between these professions. While coaching sessions may feel like strategy meetings for your life—charting out objectives and accountability plans—a therapy session can seem more exploratory, digging up roots to better understand why trees grow crookedly sometimes.

Both of these unique methodologies demonstrate how both therapists and life coaches aim to help their clients—but utilize different methods in order to do so.

When to Choose a Life Coach over a Therapist

Deciding between a life coach and therapist can be tricky, but the key is knowing what exactly you’re looking for. If your goals are about moving forward in personal development or career progression, then steering toward a life coach might just be your best route.

A life coach’s education often includes specialized certification programs focused on goal setting, motivation strategies, and accountability practices. If it’s specific achievements or lifestyle changes you’re after, this is where coaching shines brightest. They work within well-defined parameters helping clients chase down objectives from nabbing that promotion to mastering time management.

Unlike therapists who dive deep into past experiences as part of their practice—a journey requiring extensive psychological training—life coaches concentrate on where you’re headed. So if you need help mapping out professional aspirations or pushing towards personal benchmarks without delving into mental health concerns, opt for a seasoned life coach.

When Therapy is the Preferred Option

Sometimes life feels like a jigsaw puzzle with pieces scattered all over. While a life coach might help you figure out where those sky and edge pieces go, therapists are the ones who dig through the box to find that one piece you’ve been missing for years—that’s their superpower.

The Nitty-Gritty of Mental Health Disorders

Dealing with mental health disorders isn’t just about getting motivated or setting goals; it’s about healing. Therapists have specialized training in psychological theories and treatment methods which lets them offer more than just advice—they provide a space for recovery from conditions like anxiety, depression, or PTSD.

If your brain is sending SOS signals, think of therapy as your personal coast guard—it doesn’t make sense to call in a swimming coach when what you really need is someone to pull you back on board.

Past Trauma: The Ghosts That Haunt Us

We all have past experiences that haunt us. A therapist can be like that old-school librarian who knows exactly how to navigate the archives of our minds. They’re trained to guide clients through past traumas using techniques such as EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) or CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy), which aren’t found in a life coach’s toolkit.

You wouldn’t use duct tape on a leaky dam, right? Similarly, coaching strategies often don’t hold water against deep-seated trauma—you need concrete fixes only therapy can provide.

Digging Deeper Than Surface-Level Challenges

A life coach will push you by setting achievable milestones along your climb to success. But if an avalanche called depression buries you under snow at base camp two, it’s time for therapy’s search and rescue team rather than another pep talk from your climbing buddy.

To put it simply, when inner turmoil disrupts daily living or relationships get rocky because emotional baggage weighs too heavy, a therapist helps unpack those bags so you can travel light again.

What Type Of Speaker Are You?

Click below to discover your Speaker Archetype and how to start getting booked and paid to speak!

The Process of Working with a Life Coach vs. a Therapist

Imagine stepping into two different worlds—one where the future is sculpted with goals and action plans, and another where understanding your past lights the path forward. This is what it feels like when you’re deciding between working with a life coach or therapist.

Session Structure: A Blueprint for Growth vs. A Journey to Self-Discovery

A session with a life coach often resembles strategy meetings; they’re structured, goal-oriented, and packed with actionable steps. Your life coach might give you homework—tasks designed to propel you towards your objectives.

In contrast, therapy sessions are less about checklists and more about exploration. Therapists help clients dig deep into their emotions and experiences in an open-ended conversation format that may not always have immediate tasks associated but focuses on healing from within.

Duration: Sprinting vs. Marathon Running

Working with a life coach is like preparing for sprints—intense focus on achieving quick results over several weeks or months. On the other hand, therapy can be akin to marathon training—it’s generally longer-term work aiming at deeper transformation which sometimes takes years rather than months.

Interaction Styles: Collaboration vs. Supportive Guidance

Life coaching interactions are collaborative. These coaches walk side-by-side with you towards your set destination. Of course, they’ll cheer you on but expect you to do the heavy lifting. They’re like a co-pilot who helps you navigate the challenges encountered in career growth or leadership skills.

The therapeutic relationship differs significantly because therapists act more like guides through rough terrain. They support you by providing insights based on psychological expertise while helping manage emotional baggage.

Deciding whether one needs a drill sergeant for ambition or an anchor for emotional stability isn’t just beneficial—it’s crucial in making sure individuals get precisely what they need from these professional relationships.

Success Metrics in Life Coaching vs. Therapy

Life coaches and therapists track your progress differently. In the world of life coaching, success is often about hitting specific milestones. It’s goal-driven—think crossing the finish line at a marathon or nailing that dream job interview.

Evaluating Success in Life Coaching

The coach’s playbook includes setting clear objectives with their clients right from the get-go. This could be anything from improving communication skills to launching a business venture. Clients and coaches might use powerful questions to uncover goals, then create actionable plans for reaching them.

Achievement here can look like checking off those big-ticket items on your bucket list. In other words, success is concrete and quantifiable.

Gauging Therapeutic Outcomes

In therapy, measuring success leans more towards psychological well-being rather than external achievements. A therapist dives deep into an individual’s mental state aiming for healing and understanding. It’s less about doing and more about being. Think of it as nurturing a garden: You don’t just plant seeds but ensure they grow healthy by providing adequate water, sunlight, and care over time. Like growing a plant, there isn’t really an end goal because keeping a plant healthy is an ongoing process.

This means looking inward at feelings of happiness or coping mechanisms instead of outward signs like career progression or personal bests in athletics. Psychological associations recognize this approach, focusing on long-term emotional health gains which, while harder to quantify, are equally significant.

Mixing Methods for Holistic Growth

Sometimes though, life throws curveballs that require both internal reflection AND action-oriented strategies. As a result, clients may find themselves using tools from both realms—an objective-focused plan supplemented by therapeutic exploration—to pave new paths toward fulfillment.

FAQs on Choosing a Life Coach vs a Therapist

Is life coaching the same as Counselling?

No, they’re different. Life coaches target your ambitions and future plans while counsellors deal with past issues and mental health.

How do I choose a therapist or coach?

Pick a coach for goals and motivation. Choose a therapist to tackle deep emotional concerns. In both cases, always check credentials.

Are life coaches really worth it?

Absolutely, if you’re after clarity in goals and strategies to win at work or personal milestones. They push progress.

Can a life coach help with anxiety?

Sure can! While they aren’t therapists, many offer tools for managing stress, which might ease anxiety symptoms along your journey.


Choosing between a life coach and a therapist is like picking the right tool for the job. Both types of professional support have their place. Remember, when your goals are clear but you need help to reach them, a life coach steps in. But when it’s emotional healing or mental health support you’re after, lean on a therapist. Therapists have clinical training while life coaches focus on motivation and strategy.

Whatever you choose, consider who can serve you best at this chapter of your journey. Both therapists and life coaches are there for you, ready to help you unlock your potential and live life to its fullest.


Explore Related Resources

How to Become a Career Coach
Learn the steps and skills needed to become a successful career coach and help others achieve their professional dreams.
How to Become a Financial Coach: A Step-by-Step Guide
Ready to become a financial coach and transform lives with your expertise in personal finance? Here's a guide on how to begin.
Finding the Best Life Coach Near You: A Comprehensive Guide
Learn how to find the best life coach near you, evaluate their credentials, and prepare for a transformative journey in personal growth.

Learn How You Could Get Your First (Or Next) Paid Speaking Gig In 90 Days or Less

We receive thousands of applications every day, but we only work with the top 5% of speakers.

Book a call with our team to get started — you’ll learn why the vast majority of our students get a paid speaking gig within 90 days of finishing our program.

If you’re ready to control your schedule, grow your income, and make an impact in the world – it’s time to take the first step. Book a FREE consulting call and let’s get you Booked and Paid to Speak®.